I would also point out that those who are refuting many of the ATM ideas, provide an education, in some aspect or other, to posters who are not ATM, but who may not be aware or confused about that particular aspect.

As far as an ATM poster having a valid ideas here, there is at least one member of this board* who has posted in ATM and has had several papers published in the journals. Not all of that poster's ideas are ATM, but those that are, do have enough supporting evidence that I am willing to consider those ideas as possibly valid, pending more research.

* I have not identified that person. If they desire to join in that is up to them. The long time members should know who I'm talking about.

__________________
Some try to tell me, thoughts they cannot defend,... - Moody Blues.