I don't want to get caught up too much in this, but...
Interdimensional Warrior, some very lengthy posts on the subject were posted on pages 1 and 2. One of them by Jay Windley himself. You haven't said anything to this, but instead chose to respond to a personal attack.
You ask a number of questions, and multiple people respond to them in a very lengthy and detailed way. However, instead of responding to that you decide to respond to a person who has made a negative remark.
Of course, it's not nice to receive an
ad hominem, but it's even more rude to completely ignore lengthy explanations and respond to the
ad hominem instead.
I can see why you wanted a one-on-one discussion; it's quite easy to be distracted by unrelated things. Just don't get caught up in it too much, and you'll be fine and perhaps even getting some of the discussion you were looking for. As long as you don't avoid it, that is.
- Spread the Love
EDIT: Oh, sorry, I didn't see your post, two posts up.