Quote:
Originally Posted by Ari Jokimaki
Redshift in Arp's model is "More from Arp et al" stuff but briefly, redshift decreases with age of objects and quasars are newly created objects in Arp's model. But, if one starts to argue against these local quasar models, one should already know these basic issues about them, no? (Similarily, if I would argue that Big Bang theory doesn't work because it puts Earth in the center of the universe, or some other clearly false argument, then surely you would suggest that I should learn about Big Bang theory before arguing against it.)
|
Well, if you consider "redshift decreases with age of objects" as a "basic issue" of quasars then you're right that I don't know that, because that is also part of Arp's model and not an already established fact one must "learn about" before arguing against Arp's model.