Quote:
Originally Posted by Damburger
I find a lot of science fiction using different species of aliens to represent different races/viewpoints/aspects of human kind. This seems to me to be tacitly supporting the notion of biological determinism, a pseudo-scientific notion that character can be determined entirely by genetics.
|
It's not so much a tacit support, as a convenient storytelling device. Trying to come up with aliens who are as varied in personality and culture as humans, and yet all
totally different from humans, would be a massive amount of work. Even the best alien-making science fiction writers tend to make their aliens a bit monotone in culture and personality, or else so alien that thay can't really be seen as characters. There are a rare few exceptions, but they're, well, exceptional.
Star Trek wasn't going for realism. It wasn't their goal. The same is often true of "bumpy-head" aliens; they're not meant to be truly alien, just "alien enough".