Quote:
Originally Posted by korjik
And the sky will be blue tomorrow morning.
You havent said anything more profound than that.
|
You mean it is obvious that a comet has a rocky surface and will contain no significant amounts of ices/volatiles?
Quote:
Originally Posted by korjik
I can also say they will not detect any surface charging other than local floating potential. Still dosent mean anything.
|
Really? I don't see what that has to do with claiming that comets and asteroids have similar compositions.
Quote:
Originally Posted by korjik
Properly done, your claims should have an explanation on how you can get an object of 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko's size and density with only rock.
Otherwise all you have said is that the sky is blue.
|
I expect comets are produced in a similar way as asteroids.
I don't think my claims should explain "how you can get an object of 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko's size and density with only rock". That would be putting the cart before the horse; first we need to verify that comets are indeed just asteroids with special orbits, we can start speculating about why the objects would seem to possess such low densities later.
Cheers.