Quote:
Originally Posted by Nereid
[snip]
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Luxor
To Neried calling Thornhill & Talbott liars
|
I did?
Please quote the parts of my posts where I did that.
For avoidance of doubt, here is the relevant part of the last post in the series on the PDF (emphasis added):
Quote:
So, we have a document purporting to be a poster presented at an international plasma physics conference … but it seems it wasn't.
We have a document claiming copyright of all material contained in it … but it seems at least some such material is copyrighted by others.
We have a document sharing the thunderbolts.info website with pages containing the same images (at least one) and where correct attribution (and credit) is given to those images … so Thornhill and Talbott are unlikely to have been ignorant about the need for credits (they are listed as "Executive Editors" of the picture of the day section).
|
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Luxor
Are Thornhill and Talbott being (intellectually) dishonest? Is there something fraudulent about the "The Electric Comet" document"
I'll tip my hat to you Neried you are good very good!
If you are asking whether I condone intellectually dishonesty from Thornhill Talbott and so on, well then maybe you should have a look in your own back yard Neried, before you start slinging the brown stuff round!!!
|
Here's the question I asked:
Once you have had a chance to check what I have posted for yourself ATKINS (and Luxor), I'd like to know if you condone this apparent kind of behaviour.
May I conclude from your response that you do condone such behaviour?
Quote:
[snip]
Do these latest findings not provide further evidence that the current mainstream "dirty iceball" or "icy mudball" model of comet formation in the Kuiper belt has been falsified and that comets are simply asteroids which display cometary behaviour in certain situations?
What is your interpretation of these new findings, Neried?
|
I don't understand why this question is being asked, here in the ATM section; where's the ATM claim/idea/assertion? |
The customary week has passed, and while
Luxor has posted since the 5th, there is - as yet - no reply to these questions.
When may we expect a reply,
Luxor?