Quote:
Originally Posted by A.DIM
Can you show how unlikely it is for the pr.w, habiru, or hapiru to be the peoples from whom the hebrews are descendants, if not one and the same?
|
I think it is really
your responsibility to show that they
are references to the Hebrews, and
only the Hebrews. You have made that claim, but the only source you seem to have says that the name could apply to any or all of several peoples.
Quote:
Originally Posted by A.DIM
It seems my simple request for a reference from Gillianren (which I patiently await) to support her assertion has aroused something in you I can't quite figure...
Do you share her assertion that there is a single egyptian record of the hebrews?
|
I have to agree with
Daffy here. Rather than simply providing one or more references that would
disprove the statement, you are arguing against her
claim there was such a statement and insisting that she prove the statement
exists. That is a debate tactic not really suitable for a scientific discussion.
Can you provide references that would
disprove the
statement, whether it was ever made or not?