Quote:
Originally Posted by Acolyte
Nope, I don't think I know much at all - have you seen my sig? But I do see that you are making statements as truth that might be correct (or might not) in this universe but may have little bearing on the external 'whatever' outside the super-massive BH proposed by the OP.
Seems to me the thread is about speculation of something beyond what we know & you're countering by telling me that isn't how things are in our universe.
And, to be honest, I've yet to hear from anyone who has convinced me they can actually perceive of what more dimensions than what we percieve are actually like. It's OK to have math to tell us, but the math exists within our set of dimensions - it's (to me) quite possible the math will not work once you try to run it from within the extra dimensions.
I can tell you all about what it is like to be a dolphin & 'see' via sound, but it's very likely that if I became a dolphin the experience would be vastly different from what I describe before being a dolphin.
|
All you are doing is saying that there could be things working in infinite different ways than anything we know, which of course I cannot refute.
BUT I can tell you that the "horizons' you think you are talking about, that pertain to Black Hole Event Horizons are not the horizons that mainstream is using!
Actually mainstream has caused ALL of the confusion about black holes and singularities, by postulating in the first place that a 'singularity' can be 'naked' (not covered by an event horizon) Cosmic Censorship, AND, that a 'singularity' can ever expand, especially 'spherically'....SO, the FLRW EFE Schwarzschild "Inside solution" of an expanding naked "Point"singularity, which was naively done at the very start, when Einstein Naively included Lambda, for a 'spherically curved' universe to hold up the universe against that collapse of the whole universe.
BUT, In a "real" gravitational collapse, an event horizon forms, which is the only way a 'singualrity' in it's depths can form, and we have never found even ONE non-rotating Black Hole.....SO, the mathematical solution for a "point Singularity" is meaningless........until we find a non-rotating Black Hole!