View Single Post
  #13 (permalink)  
Old 13-June-2008, 03:07 PM
Chris Hillman Chris Hillman is offline
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Apr 2008
Posts: 344
Default Some attempted clarification

Quote:
Originally Posted by Nereid View Post
If LIGO/VIRGO detected an 'inspiral' signature, to what extent would that be considered a possible probe of the strong field regime?
Three quick comments:

1. To prevent misunderstanding by those who haven't read the papers I cited: gtr makes quite specific quantitative predictions for the late stage inspiral of (say) a pair of closely orbiting black holes; the "chirp-burst-ringdown-expdecay" scenario is not simply qualitative. Thus, verification of these features for dozens of mergers of stellar-mass black holes would provide strong evidence that gtr remains accurate at curvatures encountered at the event horizon of a stellar mass black hole.

2. Black hole mergers do begin to probe the nonlinear regime.

3. Supermassive black holes have smaller curvatures near their horizon than stellar-mass black holes.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Nereid View Post
Question for astronomers: out to z ~6 (say), what is the expected rate of SMBH-SMBH merger/coalescence? How tightly can the upper and lower bounds be specified, today (perhaps as a function of z)?
There are several surveys on the arXiv on expected sources of gravitational radiation, at least one of which should contain the information you seek.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Nereid View Post
IIRC, the Einstein@Home science forum has an estimate of the distance out to which one kind of inspiral could be detected, if it happened while LIGO was 'up', but I can't find it any more Does anyone know how what that distance is?
There are a number of parameters which are relevant besides distance, e.g. all ground based detectors are sensitive only with a certain frequency band; space based detectors such as LISA should be sensitive in a different band. (See the surveys for details.) But in general terms, next generation LIGO/VIRGO should be capable of detecting gravitational radiation from very distant and very violent events.
__________________
Chris Hillman

Read these PF posts. Avoid Wikipedia--- except for these versions. Read this and this suggested sticky. When asked for advice, I always say: never take advice!
Reply With Quote