View Single Post
  #1063 (permalink)  
Old 10-September-2008, 06:18 PM
Pippin Pippin is offline
Established Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Western Massachusetts
Posts: 165
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by slang View Post
Well, Pippin, why don't you explain what will happen if the proton stream hits rock? Just saying it won't and saying that stuff is hot just doesn't seem to cut it...
Funny I thought it was CERN's job to describe what would happen. I was just having a laugh about it "burrowing" when that really means destroying all atoms and molecules in its path. I do trust them enough to expect a safety cut off switch to trigger, or that any misalignment in of itself shuts down the ion flow. My personal non-scientific expectation would be that at worst it would travel a few centimeters. Even at full strength there aren't that many ions in use in comparison to the atoms of the surrounding rock and comparable density. So even a significant time before shut off, say the emergency shut off isn't triggered and one of the scientists has to kill it manually, of 5 seconds or so maximum, shouldn't pose any serious danger to the public or planet. If it was truly a concern then I don't think we'd be hearing all about the dangers mBH's and stranglets.
Or maybe I should move this to the conspiracy theory discussions!
mBHs and stranglet dangers are just an easily debunked distraction to prevent us learning they could cut a hole through the planet!!!
Reply With Quote