Quote:
Originally Posted by JustAFriend
Definitely go with Sony Vegas Movie Studio Platinum with DVD Architect.
|
Well, that's two nods for Sony. As I'm in the market to upgrade, I'll review
the reviews of the top 5 choices and post my obersvations here.
1: CyberLink PowerDirector 7 Deluxe:
- Editors' Gold award.
- The only rating below excellent is in help and support.
- If you want to author Blu-ray, you'll need the Ultra version.
- Video stabilization
- Playback in the editor was a bit jumpy. The system was tested on a DuoCore with 2 GB ram.
- Some camera compatibility issues with respect to Vista vs XP.
- A bit of information overload in terms of available options.
- Several times when their system hung for several minutes without apparent cause.
- Good, free online community where others share their custom menus, templates, and objects.
- Great auto/photo editing
2. Corel VideoStudio X2 Standard
- Ergonomically well-designed menus/functions
- Doesn't burn to Blu-ray - must use the X2 Pro version.
- Smoother playback that in PowerDirector due to use of proxy technology (edit in lower-res files; render using original files).
- Optimized for dual and quad-core processors
- Non-destructive editing (source file remains intact).
- e-mail support is free (but trust me, Corel's e-mail support sucks)
3. Sony Vegas Movie Studio Platinum 9
- Takes less effort to learn than others
- Quality software - "in depth"
- More features at this price point
- Awsome interactive tutorials
- No built-in audio editor. Can still do fades and pans. However, for just $30 more you can get the Platinum Pro pack which includes
Sound Forge Audio Studio, various themes, 3D transitions, and 1,001 sound effects.
- "The most feature-rich video editing software in it's price range."
- Blu-ray burns in this package - no upgrade necessary!
I'll skip the other two. After reading the reviews of the Gold winners, it's clear the only reasons Sony Vegas Movie Studio Platinum 9 didn't get the top award is that it has a slightly steeper learning curve, and it doesn't have a storyboard. It does have a timeline. Given it's significantly greater depth of capabilities, that's entirely understandable.
If only it had a storyboard...
So, for me, it's
Sony Vegas Movie Studio 9 Platinum Pro Pack. I'm downloading their free trial, now, and will let you know how I like it compared to the others I've used.