Well, OK...Here we go again.

a. I stumbled across the video on YouTube with the instructions on how.

a1.You can do this too. Go to youtube and search Planet Hale Civilization. You will see a screenshot video of how to do this.

b. I downloaded the hires ESA photos directly from the ESA website.

c. I enlarged the "Crater Hale Looking West" image with Photoshop. Just enlarged it using the "zoom" tool. Nothing else.

d. I found exactly what everybody else who's bothered to check it out found.

e. Then I found the link to the photobucket collection. Go to photobucket.com and search on "Crater Hale Civilization". You can do it too.

f. I think something is there.

Why don't you do it too, then you can tell me how a .jpeg artifact generates circles and triangles and shadows and is exactly the same in two different pictures taken from two different angles at two different times of the day and encoded with two different processes. That's the part that escapes me. If it was just one picture, just one .jpeg, OK, I will get on board that it's a fraud.

But it's not that simple. So instead of picking -me- apart, why don't you go try it for yourself. It's all in the public domain and really easy. Nothing is hidden nor obscured or smudged or compressed in the .tif.

As Nike says..."just do it"