View Single Post
  #53 (permalink)  
Old 22-December-2008, 08:59 PM
Jerry's Avatar
Jerry Jerry is offline
Order of Kilopi
 
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: Earth
Posts: 4,113
Default Rebuttal Paper

http://arxiv.org/abs/0807.4880v3

Quote:
Originally Posted by Stecker and Scully
The possibility of explaining the positron and electron excess recently found by the PAMELA and ATIC collaborations in terms of dark matter (DM) annihilation has attracted considerable attention...If we apply our analysis technique to the MAGIC data and assume an intrinsic power-law spectrum with index 2.02 as observed for the earlier EGRET flare at lower energies where absorption is negligible, we find that the luminosity of the MAGIC flare was similar to that of the earlier EGRET flare. In fact, the MAGIC flare was ~3 times brighter. This luminosity estimate could not be obtained using the analysis adopted by the MAGIC group, since all of the data points that they started from were affected by intergalactic absorption.
...Which, if they are correct, means I=ATIC estimates of Cosmic ray energy levels are likely too high, and therefore they could travel intergalactly without attenuation by the CMB. The plot thickens...
__________________
jwj

It's a big universe out there...is it really unwinding, really burning out?
Reply With Quote