Quote:
Originally Posted by tusenfem
You are incorrect here, what I drew was correct, and apparently you have not learned much through the zillion Q&A threads you started.
According to mainstream you can be anywhere in the universe and look in all directions. You will find that everything moves away from you (barring small local effects) and the further something is away from you the faster it moves. This would indeed imply that AB and CD grow faster than weC (as viewed from "we") and using the Hubble relation you might even calculate at what rate that is.
.
|
Look I dont agree with your drawings at all. I was just correcting your error. so that your diagram matches what you were saying.
If AB grows faster than weA then from the vantage point of A ... B is moving faster away from A than WE is.
Here is your diagram from the point of view of A.
B--A--WE
B----A---WE
B----A
WE---A
So from the vantage point of A ... YOU are stating that even though they are equally as close B has moved away faster than A.
Please explain why you feel that objects act differently for A than they do for WE!!!!
This would seem to make even more spectacular conclusion that woud be deduced into WE is the center of the universe, which is very unlikely.
Again the change I made was to try to fix your graph to fit in with what YOU are saying.