I voted for "no way". I usually post in ATM and it seemed to me a disparagement of ATM to take it out of Space & Astronomy and put it with Conspiracy Theories. I don't see a particular need to subdivide ATM. As long as there is some general relevance to Space & Astronomy, it should be okay to post there. I understand that moderating has sometimes been burdensome in ATM, but that's partly because the BAUT members don't attack with the same relish they used to have. This has caused a few too many rules to appear in ATM, which sometimes have the effect of damping discussion. I say keep ATM where it is and let the fighting resume! (Does anyone remember JS Princeton?)