Dear
crosscountry why would ANYTHING be deleted? Do you think we have something to hide? I would be highly insulted if my message,
mmfiore's or
swift's message would be deleted and quit the board.
mmfiore got rather agitated by
my message to him where I state (as a participant, not as moderator, because then it would be in red and I tend not to moderete threads in which I am a participant however small) that after 8 pages of thread, he has not shown anything about his Super relativity idea that is in any way convincing that it has any merit.
Fortis is mainly on this. Instead of replying to my complaints, he feels attacked by me mentioning that I do not see any reason for that whole thread.
Maybe I should not have mentioned that?
Maybe
mmfiore feels that I am right but does not want it true.
Anyway, I still feel the same.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by crosscountry
we ask people to defend their ATM ideas and ban them when the don't answer the questions - now we ban them when they do answer the questions. This is ridiculous.
|
We only ban/suspend people when they do not answer direct questions. An answer "i do not know" is a valid answer.
mmfiore was not banned because he "answered the question" but because his behaviour, for which he has been warned before.
here (before I was a participant)
here
here
And that is only in this thread.
And then we apparently let
this message just pass by.
And whether
mmfiore really answers the question is a matter of debate, it took several tries by
Fortis to get
mmfiore to acknowledge that he cannot "predict" masses of particles if he cannot use the mass of said particle as an
input parameter!!
So, over-moderation? I don't think so.