Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Sam5
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Ian Goddard
The counter you initially raised against my response to the poster was that any expanding finite region has a center of expansion because it has a center, which I believe I debunked. |
You haven’t debunked anything, and neither you nor I know what’s beyond our visible limits or whether the universe has a “center” or not. If it is infinite, it most likely doesn’t have a center. But if it’s finite, it most likely does.
This is the very same question that confronted Newton 350 years ago, and nobody knows the answer to it. |
Once again you've switched the issue, this time from "Can a finite expanding object with known edges expand without a center of expansion?" to "Does the universe have a center?" I claimed to debunk your view on the former,
not any view on the latter. So you counter a straw man.