dgruss wrote:
Quote:
|
But periodicity or not, that is a separate phenomenon from the question of whether or not they are local. Hawkins other study did not find evidence for QSO time dilation.
|
I agree - but isn't the periodicity one of Arp's main evidences for his quasar ejection theory? Also, isn't one of the main points of Hawkins' periodicity paper that Arp (and others) massively overestimated their claimed significances for the periodicity results. This doesn't do Arp's claims much good.
BTW, I think they're different Hawkins'.