Quote:
|
Originally Posted by milli360
In the first response, it is yourself that is misinterpreting the Einstein paper, not Einstein. He got that part right--but you keep insisting on a misinterpretation of the theory in order to insist that it's wrong. That's your fault, no one else's.
|
We keep telling him that, but he just won't accept it.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by kjavds
But circular path scenarios must be resolved with GR, there's no choice.
|
Not "must". It's easier with GR, but you can do it with SR. Einstein did it with SR in Section 4 of the 1905 paper, in fact.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Sam5
In order for me to answer the questions of four or five guys, I’ll need a little time to consider their questions.
|
Your only response to my question has been, "
You answer your own question, Sean!" so I hope you're not including me in the "four or five guys."
Maybe I'm the fifth guy.