Quote:
|
Originally Posted by lyndonashmore
He has worked out the recoil velocity of the electron and, when he finds that he cannot equate the energy of the photon with that picked up in recoil, he says "where has the energy gone" . In transwerse waves they are separate entities. One deducts the energy picked up in recoil from the energy of the photon and it is this that produces the redshift.
Cheers,
Lyndon
|
You know, you could settle this real easy. Instead of a lot of word salad, why don't you just produce the quantitative analysis showing the conservation of momentum and energy in your process? Sylas has produced his work, you haven't. Sylas has the calculations to back up his claims, you don't, it's that simple. Until you produce the analysis, your rebuttals to Sylas, without showing the calculations, are not very convincing and make it appear your main effort is to avoid having to provide the calculations. Which makes me think you either are unable to produce the calculations or you could, but don’t dare because you have done them and know they show you to be wrong.