I was really not clear in what I was saying.
I was trying to say that if you can discuss a movie about vulcanology (the core) in the Bad Astronomy Movies section because it is about Bad Science in the Media (even though it doesn't directly talk about astronomy), then you should be able to discuss Tom Cruise's purposeful lies about science in that same section cause it is about Bad Science in the Media.
Also, I was trying to say that Psychiatry is as necessary to space as other sciences are, so you can't argue something like "Psychiatry doesn't belong in an astronomy forum cause it isn't linked to space" (which someone said).
EDITTED because it was unreadable
EDITTED AGAIN: I realize that for some odd reason in the other thread I started arguing that geology and such aren't related to astronomy, but I don't actuatlly believe that. I feel that every science is actually a branch of physics, and therefore they are all closely related. I must have been high on sugar after eating that snickers bar :roll:
|