Originally Posted by Gillianren

I stand by the scenario I posted in the other thread, and if anyone wants to prove to me otherwise, they must explain the motivations in the alternate scenario where I ask for them. (did anyone actually read the alternate scenario? I thought I summed it up pretty well, but it was so close to the end of the thread that I'm not sure anyone caught it.)

if another thread on the same subject starts, I'll probably haul that scenario out again. (this isn't really a thread on the subject; it's a thread on what's wrong with threads on the subject.)