View Single Post
  #26 (permalink)  
Old 23-September-2005, 05:34 PM
Nereid Nereid is online now
Order of Kilopi
 
Join Date: Mar 2004
Posts: 10,941
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by cyrek1
To All

I do not believe in 'black holes' which I consider to be a concentration of neutron star positively charged congregates to the surrounding negative charged gases as shown in the center of galaxies.
Can you show us your math on this please?

I'm interested in two different perspectives:
1) what do you consider the massive, condensed object to be, that astromomers refer to as 'black hole', wrt to good observations (e.g. in certain X-ray binaries, SagA*, the nuclei of M31 and NGC 4258)?
2) what prevents the collapse of a neutron star, to a BH, once the gravitational pressure exceeds the neutron degeneracy pressure?

If you are rejecting at least part of General Relativity (GR), please say so.
Quote:
Matter is structured in such a way that it will never collapse. The hydrogen atom is an example. In its ground state in open space, it does not collapse.
OK, so from this I infer that you are, indeed, rejecting at least part of GR (pace "I am a self educated amateur cosmologist who relies on real physics for support").

Collapse is inevitable, at least locally, for all bodies in mutual orbits (per GR, as verified by Hulse and Taylor). Collapse is also inevitable once the gravitational pressure exceeds certain thresholds - to various solid states (upon cooling), to electron degenerate states, to neutron degenerate states, ... so all H atoms 'in open space' will, sooner or later, no longer be 'in open space'.