Quote:
|
Originally Posted by P.Asmah
Good ideas, particularly this one.
|
Thanks.
Quote:
|
Mainstreamers could probably also help out with this, instead of effectively saying, "If you ain't already done the math ... we don't want to know!"
|
It seems that the purpose of this ATM section of BAUT is being misunderstood.
This ATM section is an opportunity for anyone with an ATM idea to propose it, and have other BAUT members
challenge and question the idea. Should the proposer (or anyone else) wish to develop the idea further, to address those challenges and questions, they are free to do so - indeed, welcome to do so.
This purpose is clearly set out in
the BAUT rules:
Quote:
13. Alternative Concepts
If you have some idea which goes against commonly-held astronomical theory, then you are welcome to argue it here. Before you do, though READ THIS THREAD FIRST. This is very important. Then, if you still want to post your idea, you will do so politely, you will not call people names, and you will defend your arguments. Direct questions must be answered in a timely manner.
People will attack your arguments with glee and fervor here; that's what science and scientists do. If you cannot handle that sort of attack, then maybe you need to rethink your theory, too. Remember: you came here. It's our job to attack new theories. Those that are strong will survive, and may become part of mainstream science.
Additionally, keep promotion of your theories and ideas to only those Against the Mainstream threads which discuss them. Hijacking other discussions to draw attention to your ideas will not be allowed.
If it appears that you are using circular reasoning, depending on long-debunked arguments, or breaking any of these other rules, you will receive one warning, and if that warning goes unheeded, you will be banned.
|
If you are looking for someone to help you develop your idea (other than through having it challenged and questioned), then BAUT's ATM section is the wrong place for that purpose.