Hi have suspended MacM for 3 days for a few reasons. One is his attempt to dodge the issue his his misunderstanding parts of Special Relativity, and put the blame for the discrepency on Worzel and Nereid.

I have little hope that when he returns MacM will be willing to have a real discussion about the difference between his viewpoint and SR as understood in the mainstream. Should this sort of dodgy behavior continue, we will discuss whether to ban him altogether.

I also see no point in keeping this circular thread open. If someone has something new to add, please PM a mod, and we will reopen it. At the moment, it is merely a time-wasting source of contention slowing analysis of other ATM ideas.

__________________
Forming opinions as we speak