View Single Post
  #65 (permalink)  
Old 10-May-2006, 08:46 AM
gaetanomarano's Avatar
gaetanomarano gaetanomarano is offline
Established Member
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Italy
Posts: 1,833
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Bob B.
NASA should therefore have a considerable amount of launch experience with the CLV/CEV before the start of the lunar missions. I’m not sure this is something gaetanomarano has taken into consideration in making his pessimistic assessment of the 1.5 launch architecture.
you are too optimist about the CEV and its use for ISS because:

- due to the changes in its design (5-seg., etc.) and other possible delays I don't think that an orbital-CEV will fly before 2014-2015

- in 2015 the orbital-CEV will be only one of many crew vehicles available for the ISS (Digital-Soyuz, Shenzhou, Kliper or a new russian vehicle)

- the ISS' crew will remain of 3 for great part of its time

- since the ISS is international, only 1/3 of the crew will be american (and many times will fly with the Soyuz, like to-day)

- Europe, Russia and China can't spend $200+ million per seat for the CEV (and don't want to spend it, since one Soyuz-seat costs $20M)

the sum of these points is that an orbital-CEV will fly only for the crew rotation of american astronauts, then, in 2014-2018 (when the moon missions begin), the CEV will (probably) fly 3-5 times max, not a great amount of launch experience

consider also, that, a big launch experience, don't means to avoid all problems and delays (see the 25y. experience of the Shuttle...)

.
Reply With Quote