Quote:
Originally Posted by HenrikOlsen
Questions raised by A which N should be accountable for answering is In My Higly-biased Opinion:
1) A: Could you give me a reference to those results?
2) A: I can't see how my idea will influence muon half-life under SR, please clarify.
3) This one depends entirely on {words}
4) A: Please show me how my theory is connected to SR.
5) A: I can't see how my idea will influence muon half-life under SR, why do you think that observation is relevant?
Or the short one:
1) Why?
2) How?
3) Why?
4) How?
5) So?
|
1). This answer indicates the proponent hasn't done their research.
2). Same as 1 with the addition of "or doesn't understand the mainstream theory."
3). Yeah, it would depend on what makes the ATM idea inconsistent.
4). Same as 2
5). Again, same as 2.
This basically goes back to Gillianren's statement about understanding what's actually wrong with the mainstream idea, not what you think is wrong or because you don't like the implications of the mainstream idea.