What would be a bigger shock? Aliens that are not religious without proof, aliens that are not religious with proof, aliens that are religious without proof or aliens that are religious with proof?

On a different note...If we are the first aliens they encounter, and they are the first aliens we encounter...who do you think will be more excited?

I can see it already...
Human: "I knew we werent alone! I just knew it!"
Alien: "Me too!"
*both laugh*