Here is what you told Bogie.
http://www.bautforum.com/report.php?p=824490
I prefer a different way of describing the GR/QM incompatibility - there is a regime (the Planck) within which application of both GR and QM produces wild inconsistencies ("a confusion of infinites", if you will). However, the inconsistency is considerably deeper than the infinities - the very structures (of GR and QM) are incompatible. Or, if you prefer, there is no way to unite the two theories - we must abandon one, or both, and create a new theory (or theories) that have completely different structures (but which 'reduce to' GR and QM, respectively, in their limits).
Which is exactly what Posts 1, 2, and 3 are.
The Unification CANNOT take place at T=0, or T= 10^-35, or T= 10^-43, because it never existed.
The Unification MUST take place, just as you asked for, at the Planck regime, and that is just as this shows, in the Massive Black Holes! They make our 'space' (gravity) for the 3 forces we know (EM, Strong and Weak Nuclear) to be able to frolic in.
But after watching Hawking's Paradox this weekend, I now see what I am really up against!!!
I realize that Posts 1, 2, and 3 are LONG and cover so much territory that it is difficult for people to begin a conversation at any given point of it, but if can't be covered here, on this one thread, maybe I can begin individual issues, one at a time, in ATM, that can be covered that way.
Let's just start with the main one then.
The Laws Of Thermodynamics.
Please explain why this cannot be so.
So, what does this mean? If the universe is operating under the Laws Of Thermodynamics of an OPEN system, then the Second Law of Black Hole Dynamics does not apply, and when considering the creation of a SMBH, a Cosmic Black Hole, it is perfectly legal to do the time reversal I have shown to find the progenitor…the Naked Singularity (it’s not starting the universe) that makes a SMBH