'I don't know where you are up to, so I am unable to make any pertinent comments.

However, in terms of the overall thread, I think this is a seriously flawed summary.

Let's see how you revise your summary once you've read the whole thread.'

Oh dear, being wrong seems to be a regular ocurrance for me on this forum

Yes I have read more and yes my initial post WAS a seriously flawed summery. I still have not read the post in its entireity but I do know that I currently possess NO ES literature that would count as a suitable proof that Thompson's criticisms are in error. As I have not read all the posts I cannot be certain that no other person has brought such proof to bear on the subject, but right now I for one have no choice but to consider ES bunk.