Very ironic. But had it been the smoking gun it would have been curtains for Jay's "good" name.
You have actually hit the crux spot on.
Jay only saw the new Sibrel missing reel so could not possibly be justified in describing the video as 'rehashed'. I cannot see any other meaning.
Jay got lucky but that should not be his defence.
Some very childish behaviour on the part of Jonathon Ploegman by resorting to name calling has probably finished Apollo Hoax as a serious discussion board.
Now the Hoax believers will probably feel they hit a raw nerve. Perhaps they did?