This thread at Apollohoax has turned into just the type of thing that Mr. Badastronomer has managed to keep out of this forum (and told me off a couple of times too [img]/phpBB/images/smiles/icon_wink.gif[/img] ). It started out as nothing, and has developed into an attack on Jays credibility which is totally unjustified. I believe Jay was totally justified in his review at Amazon. I've seen the film, and Jays comments are accurate. He does not imply he's seen the vid, but he knows enough about it anyway from descriptions from those who have seen it to make an informed judgement. Sometimes Jay is just too damn moral for his own good. He's removed his review just in case someone may get the wrong impression from his statements. However, which ever way you look at it, his review was spot on.