Originally Posted by jersey nick

Disclaimer - I'm a Penn Jillette fan, and also a big fan of astronomy and I discovered BA through pennradio.com.

That having been said, as a noted skeptic, Penn really should be able to spot blatant fallacies. Penn clearly stated after the first Plait v. Rogan show that Rogan is completely wrong. Penn was certainly going for the entertainment value of Joe Rogan being an agressive nut-job.