Interesting. So Primack's argument is that the velocity dispersion decreases at greater distance because of the shape of the orbits (highly elliptical) and the line of sight. Still, I'm curious what makes them think that the planetary nebula specifically should all have the highly elliptical orbits when they suggest other components of the system should have more circular orbits.
Of course the planetary nebula are not the only tracers of dark matter in elliptical galaxies. Some of the galaxies that indicated no dark matter - also indicated no dark matter by other means I believe. I have a file on that. I'll have to check it later.
__________________
"The scientist who asks the right question reconnoiters a new patch of the unknown, and may, with luck, bring it within the constricted but expanding boundaries of the known."
~Timothy Ferris (The Red Limit) 1982
|