|
| If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|||||||
| Register | FAQ | Members List | Calendar | Mark Forums Read |
![]() |
|
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Search this Thread | Display Modes |
|
|||
|
Hello!
Like I said; this is a Dumb Question. I just finished watching 'Goldeneye' for the 417th time; and something's been bugging me about the Arecibo observatory they use as a set in the film. I know absolutely nothing about the observatory other than a) it's bloody huge, and b) it's had Famke Jenssen, Isabella Scorupco and Jodie Foster running around it from time to time; so overall it's a pretty spectacular place. My question concerns that triangular thingamadoohickey hanging over the dish - what I'm assuming is the observatory's reciever proper. The triangular thingamadoohickey hangs over the dish; along with another semicircular whatsit suspended under the triangular thingamadoohickey on a circular track. Clearly; the semicircular whatsit is designed to rotate on the track. This is shown in the film; but I'm not entirely sure that's real or a special effect. Since the observatory can only see in one direction - a visual cone straight up - and since rotating the reciever wouldn't change that - it'd simply show straight up at a different angle - my question is: a) What exactly is the rotating semicircular whatsit? b) Why does the semicircular whatsit rotate? In other words; what advantage does a rotating semicircular whatsit have over an average, gardern-variety stationary semicircular whatsit have? (I thought about compensating for the Earth's rotation; but a simple and cheap computer program ought to be able to deal with that much better than a complex and costly rotating semicircular whatsit.) c) Unrelated question: that little control room at the apex of the triangular thingamadoohickey must be to hold equipment required for the reciever. Since the dish reflects all recieved energy directly at the reciever; is there any danger to a human operator in that control room? d) Totally unrelated question: Neat looking site or not; why does some godforsaken place way out in the middle of Puerto Rico get all the real gorgeous babes running around it? ![]() Note - any unscientific terminology in this post is entirely intentional. ![]() Thanx! |
|
||||
|
How about if you read the links below and come back with the questions they don't answer?
About the observatory More technical than the above From space.com Photos Well, I'll take a shot, anyway: a, b: The observatory can be aimed to a limited extent by moving the focus. The focus is the "gregorian focus", which is the sort of geodesic-looking thing hanging down from the suspended track. c: The control room isn't at or near the focus; it's on a hill next to the observatory. In any case, I don't think there'd be enough energy to be dangerous, but I could be wrong. d: Because astronomy is SEXY!
__________________
Everything I need to know I learned through Googling. |
|
|||
|
I believe it was Carl Sagan in Cosmos who made the statement that all of the energy every captured by all of the world's radio telescope is less than that of a single falling snowflake.
From that statement, I would say that even Arecibo's dish focusing all the radio waves it collects would present no danger to a human at the focus. Rob
__________________
"Crackpot theories 1 : Regular theories a billion." Fry |
|
||||
|
Except when it is being used as an interplanetary radar. I don't think you want to be anywhere near it when it transmits a multi-megawatt pulse at Venus, an asteroid, or other object.
![]()
__________________
Any day you wake up on "the right side of the dirt" is a good day. T. Anderson |
|
|||
|
Lol - OK; thanks for the link ToSeek; I should have done that first; except my browser's a bit squirrely at the moment. (I get one web-page and 20 popups every time I click - pain in the arse; I tell you.)
OK; let's see if I've got this straight - and this time; I'm not going to use semi-amusing terms. OK; the triangular platform is just that: A platform upon which the actual reciever is mounted. The semicircular track holds and moves the focus - the geodesic mounted underneath. The reason it has to do this (And this is where it gets hazy for me; let's see if I've got it straight), is that the dish isn't a parabola; which would send any incoming signal to a central reciever, but circular; which doesn't. So; the track rotates and moves the geodesic to the spot where the particular radio signals are focussed; and collects them. OK; I think that's right. Thanx! (BTW - I'm aware the little control room at the apex isn't the control room for the dish itself; I just assume it's a maintenance and monitoring spot...or something like that.) Thanx again! |
|
||||
|
Quote:
__________________
Everything I need to know I learned through Googling. |
|
||||
|
Quote:
http://www.geocities.com/Area51/Dime...9/extracom.htm |
|
|||
|
Quote:
"We assume that the planet Earth is in peril and we need help. We think that the acquaintance of our drama - human degradation, political abuses, nuclear weaponry, environmental threats - by the neighbors and the resultant experience exchange increases our chances of being successful in the solution of some of those problems." So their main reason for wanting to send messages is to beg the aliens to "save us from ourselves." :roll: |
|
||||
|
The one thing I can't figure out is why they need a dish the size of Arecibo to simply contact a satellite.
__________________
Freedom For Fission A breath of fresh Iodine-131 |